Furore as gay group asked to take down sign


January 21, 2013 – 7:14PM

Leesha McKenny

Urban Affairs Reporter

Furore … John Chedid, Mayor of Parramatta. Photo: Ben Rushton BGR

Parramatta’s Lord Mayor is facing a social media backlash after a gay and lesbian youth group invited to a council family fun day was asked to remove its ‘‘offensive’’ signage.

Council staff told the group that a banner promoting its “support services for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, same-sex attracted and gender-diverse young people, their families and communities” was inappropriate at last week’s Rediscover the River festival, its acting managing director, Terence Humphreys, said.

Fearing “a potentially toxic environment”, Twenty10 – which had been invited by council to set up a kite-making stall – decided to pack up and leave instead.

The offending banner … there was a request to take it down.

Twenty10 apologised on Facebook to those who may have noticed its absence, but said it could not support an event if the sign displaying ‘‘who we are and the services we provide’’ had been ‘‘deemed to contain offensive language’’.

“We had school-aged clients there, volunteers and staff who were very distressed by the incident,” Mr Humphreys told Fairfax Media.

“It sends a really horrible message to the people of Parramatta that it wasn’t OK to be same-sex attracted, gender diverse in a family event like the Rediscover the River.”

Council has been inundated with complaints as news of the January 17 incident has spread.

A change.org petition calling for an apology had attracted more than 7500 signatures as of Monday night.

Council said in a statement that organisers asked that two banners be removed “in response to numerous complaints by members of the public”, but at no stage did it request Twenty10 to leave.

It declined to say what aspect of the sign was found to be offensive.

“Council regrets any inconvenience or offence taken by its actions and values the efforts and contribution of Twenty10 in servicing at-risk youth,” it said.

“Council has enjoyed a positive relationship with Twenty10 over some time and hopes to continue to work in partnership over the coming years.”

But Twenty10 was still awaiting a response from the Liberal Lord Mayor, John Chedid – whose staff it claims had made the request – or it will consider lodging a complaint with the Anti-Discrimination Board.

“We specifically want an apology and reassurance from the Lord Mayor’s office that their staff will undertake some anti-discrimination training,” he said.

“To this point we haven’t heard back from him.”

Fairfax Media was told Cr Chedid was unavailable to comment on Monday, as the issue divided some of his fellow councillors.

Councillor and former mayor Lorraine Wearne said she was happy to apologise for any offence caused, but the response – including naming staff on Facebook – was an overreaction.

“These things can generate a life of their own and can feed off themselves and that’s what concerns me here – that this is going to be bigger than Ben-Hur with no cause other than the fact that someone asked a stall to please take down a banner,” she said.

“If they had [refused to pull] the banner down, that would have been the end of it.”

Labor’s Julia Finn said the council’s reasoning was inadequate.

“I think it’s quite disgraceful and embarrassing that we did this,” she said.

“Would we stop doing [ethnic-focused events] because a racist person complained?”

But independent councillor, Paul Garrard, said the council had made the right call as the family day was no place for “semi-political” groups.

“They shouldn’t have been there, in the same fashion Right to Life weren’t there,” he said.

“Whether one is for or against the issues the gays were pushing on that occasion, that was not the place to be doing it.”


Read more

Apology demanded after gay and lesbian groups’ signs deemed offensive

6 thoughts on “Furore as gay group asked to take down sign

  1. The second you say ‘the gays’ is when your argument is made invalid. Really hope there was nothing from the Salvation Army there, wouldn’t want to spark a religious war.

  2. Advertising what you do isn’t exactly pushing an issue. And offering support to a persecuted group in society is hardly in the same league “semi-politically” as Right to Life interfering in other people lives.

    It seems nonsensical to invite a community organisation like this if promoting their existence and purpose beyond that event wasn’t part of the reason for them being there.

    “So, tell me about Parramatta Kindergarten.”

    “We make chocolate crackles.”


    “We just make chocolate crackles.”

    “But presumably-”

    “No, no, we go to family fun days and make chocolate crackles. That’s all. And toffee apples.”

    ” ‘kay…”

  3. “Issues the gays were pushing”??? They appeared to be pushing services to support a vulnerable group of young people and were invited to have a stall. Appalling reasoning by Mr Garrad!

  4. Imagine the horror if they removed the sign and there was a woman discretely breastfeeding her child behind it! How would Koch have coped?

    • How would the moral crusaders cope? All their fears in one go – an uncovered breast being used for what Nature intended and not to titillate some sleazy old fart or pimple-bedecked freak.

      A rampant bunch of “teh_gays”.

      How would they cope with a breast-feeding lesbian mum?

  5. In all seriousness, I wonder when the likes of Koch and this council are going to start taking responsibility for the anger they cause. All this talk of media storms, things getting out of control, overreactions etc: you can’t blame the horses for bolting if you leave the stable door open.

What do YOU think about this?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s